This is one of the oldest cemeteries in the county. The cemetery surveys have been supplemented with information obtained from published obituaries, Garnett Funeral Home Records and personal knowledge of family members, county residents and other sources.
Directions: This cemetery is located in the woods near where the old Bayport Hotel stood. All the headstones were removed by someone years ago. They spent several years in the basement of the Old Jailhouse. Sometime in the 1980's they were taken to the May-Stringer Heritage House Museum for safe keeping because every time they were replaced they disappeared yet again. Over the years this cemetery has been vandalised time and time again. Because of the ongoing vandalism,desecration and remoteness of its location, I am declining to publish the exact location of this cemetery.
| NAME | BIRTH | DEATH | COMMENTS/NOTES |
| Ayers, Mollie A. | 27 Dec 1881 | 1 Jun 1905 | |
| Barrington, Rev. A. M. | 4 Apr 1820 | 20 Mar 1886 | |
| Garrason, Isaac Maj. | no date | 10 Jul 1865 | |
| Hope, William Lee | 18 Oct 1869 | 17 Jan 1879 | Son of S. E. & M. H. |
| Johnson, Greenlief | 7 Mar 1849 | 17 Aug 1880 | |
| Johnson, Hannah | 14 Feb 1814 | 24 Jul 1899 | |
| Johnson, John E. | 21 Mar 1823 | 3 Jun 1859 | Born Rye, N. H., Drowned with Son at Bay Port |
| Johnson, John P. | 28 Jan 1853 | 3 Jun 1859 | Father; John E., Drowned with his father at Bay Port |
| Nissen, Anne Katherine | 3 Apr 1874 | 18 Jul 1881 | Father; Jens Norskov, Mother; Marie Nissen, Born In Denmark, Died At Cedar Key |
| Nissen, Marie | 10 Jul 1850 | 16 Jun 1886 | father: Jens Norskov; Born In Denmark, Died Bayport |
| Perry, Garland | 1930 | 1953 | |
| Roach, Annie | 1851 | 20 Jun 1898 | At Rest |
| Rouse, Gussie Timmon | 1905 | 1954 | |
| Sharpe, Arrementer E. | no date | no date | |
| Underwood, William. D. | 15 Mar 1825 | 28 Mar 1859 | |
| Wright, Rev. Johnson | 1816 | 17 May 1877 | Age 51 yrs; birth year calculated from age at death |