return to Town Histories
BENNINGTON (continued)
Chapter XX.
Aldrich, Lewis Cass, editor; History of Bennington County, Vt. © 1889, pages 265-
In the fall of 1776 the regiment, under the command of Colonel Moses Robinson,
was honorably discharged, the campaign in the vicinity of Ticonderoga for the
year being ended, one company from Bennington having previously been ordered to
return and assist in forwarding a supply of flour for the use of the army.
Nathan Clark, chairman of the committee at Bennington, had answered the request
of the commissary, saying "that one thousand bushels of wheat had been collected
and was being ground at the mills, and would be forwarded as fast as possible,
adding "that the militia having left us almost to a man renders it very
difficult to furnish assistance to convey what we have already on hand," and
suggesting the feasibility of discharging some of the militia for such service.
Commissary Yancy gave as a reason why he had made application to the Bennington
committee "that there was danger of too long a delay from the number of
disaffected persons in and about Albany to obtain provisions from that place,"
where it would naturally be most convenient
to obtain them, other conditions being equal.
A roll of one of the companies from Bennington which was in service on this
occasion has been found among the papers of Captain Elijah Dewey who commanded
it. The following is a copy: "Payroll of Captain Elijah Dewey's company in
Colonel Moses Robinson's regiment of the militia in the service of the United
States of America, Mount Independence, 1776, Elijah Dewey, captain; Ebenezer
Walbridge, first lieutenant; Thomas Jewett, second lieutenant; Nathaniel
Fillmore, ensign; Joseph Rudd, Daniel Harman, John Fay, sergeants; John Smith,
Jedediah Merrill, Thomas Story, corporals; privates, Samuel Cutler, Ezekiel
Harman, Joseph Wickwire, Daniel Kinsley, Jonathan Parsons, Andrew Weaver, Abner
Marble, Phineas Scott, Aaron Haynes, Silas Harman, Joseph Robinson, Ezekiel
Smith, Seth Porter, David Powers, Hopestill Armstrong, Joseph Willoughby, Samuel
Hunt, Joshua Carpenter, Othneil Green, Philip Matteson, Roswell Moseley."
In January, 1777, a committee of the New York convention made a report, alleging
"that countenance and encouragement was given to the disaffected (on the grants)
by false representations that persons of much influence and authority in the
neighboring States were favorable to them, and that it was the intention of the
Continental Congress to aid and assist them in obtaining their independence." It
charged that these false statements had "received great weight and authority
from the appointment of Seth Warner to be colonel of a
regiment to be raised in that part of the State, and to appoint his own officers
independent of the State of New York, the said Warner being well known to have
been "principally concerned in divers riots, outrages and cruelties committed in
direct opposition to the former government, and recommended the disbanding of
"the said regiment directed to be raised by Mr. Warner."
Although Congress did not accede to the desire in the petition of Jonas Fay and
others, that this territory should be recognized as a free and independent
State, and that delegates should be admitted to seats in Congress, still it did
not, as was urged by the New York friends, "express any opinion on the merits of
the controversy, evidently intending to leave it, at least for the present, to
be determined by the parties themselves, without the intervention of Congress."
Neither did it recommend the "recall of the commissions to Colonel Warner and
the officers under him, or the disbanding of the obnoxious regiment."
The inhabitants of Bennington were not behind others at this time in declaring
by representation at Westminster, "that they would at all times thereafter
consider themselves as a free and independent State by the name of New
Connecticut, and that the people had the sole right of governing themselves in
such manner and form as they in their wisdom should chose not repugnant to any
resolve of the honorable, the Continental Congress." Soon afterwards at Windsor
"in general convention, June 4, 1777," an additional declaration was made and
officially signed by Jonas Fay, secretary, among other important matters
changing the name to "Vermont." Another act of this convention was the
appointment on the 7th day of June of the 18th of the then month "to be observed
as a day of public fasting and prayer throughout the State," and this first
proclamation for a fast in Vermont, signed by Jonas Fay as secretary, was
issued, and the day was observed in Bennington, and through the State very
generally.
The facts which have been alluded to out of the very many prominent ones which
might be cited, will give an idea of the prominence of many of the men of this
town, and impress upon the mind in some degree the continual strain for thirteen
long years endured by its inhabitants in resisting the enchoachments of New
York, and latterly in aiding by unexampled promptness and zeal the colonies in
their opposition to the mother country, in her endeavor to tax and oppress them
with her unjust laws.
It seems very remarkable that during the long controversy of the settlers with
the province of New York, in which there were so many altercations, so many
skirmishes, so many hand to hand collisions and encounters, in which firearms
were commonly used as weapons both of offense and defense, there was not the
loss of a single life. But many a Yorker was handled in such a manner as to make
him wary of being again caught within the lines of the "grants," while the
forbearance exhibited by the inhabitants towards those endeavoring to deprive
them of their homes, and the firmness shown at all times for protecting their
justly acquired possessions, without going to extreme measures, is the only way
to account for the strange though not deadly experiences of the times.
The history of Bennington can no more be written without telling the story of
the battle of the l6th of August, 1777, than "the play of 'Hamlet' can be acted
with Hamlet left out," which is the ground upon which justification is claimed
in giving it a place here The tale of the earlier settlers must be told to show
of what stuff the pioneers of the town, both men and women, were made of, and
the part taken in this and other scenes by the people of Bennington clearly
belongs to the town.
In the spring of 1777 Ticonderoga was in possession of our forces under General
St. Clair. General Burgoyne had succeeded General Carlton in Canada, and the
campaign of 1776 had ended disastriously for our cause, leaving Lake Champlain
by th destruction of our shipping under the full command of the enemy. The
advancing army under Burgoyne numbered about nine thousand men, well armed and
equipped, and was made up mostly of veterans from England and Germany, with
great numbers of Canadians and Tories, and a large body of Indians. The plan
which it was expected would be carried out was for Burgoyne to sweep down to
Albany, driving before him all opposition and spreading devastation upon his
right and left wings, expecting large numbers of Tories would seek his
protection, and with an increased army rejoicing in a victorious campaign, he
would meet one that with like military glory should come up the Hudson River
from New York, thus separating New England from the other States.
With anxiety to muster the regiment of Colonel Warner for the Continental army,
the "the town had at a meeting held the 14th of April, voted to raise £240
lawful money ($Soo) to be paid in bounties of $40 to each man from the town that
should enUst in such regiment."
The State Council of Safety "had adjourned to Bennington in July, where it
continued in permanent session until after the surrender of Burgoyne in October,
in the room before mentioned, in the tavern of Landlord Fay." Of the original
thirteen members, five, viz.: Stephen and Jonas Fay, Samuel and Moses Robinson
and Nathan Clark were from Bennington. "Of the six most active members of the
council, as shown by such minutes of its proceedings as have been preserved,
were Jonas Fay, Nathan Clark and Moses Robinson," of Bennington.
The regiment of militia under Colonel Moses Robinson composed among others of
two companies from Bennington, the roll of one of which has already been given,
was called into service in June, and "was at Mount Independence, when that fort,
together with Ticonderoga, was evacuated by St. Clair July 6, 1777." He had made
the best preparation he could with the means and men at his disposal for the
defense of Ticonderoga and the head of the lake, but on the approach of Burgoyne
with so formidable an army he felt compelled to
abandon them. On his retreat the rearguard of the army, "under the command of
Colonel Seth Warner, was overtaken the next day, July 7, at Hubbardton, by a
large body of the enemy, and often a brave resistance was overpowered by numbers
and obliged to give way." The place designated as the rallying point for
Warner's scattered regiment was Manchester, where soon after some one hundred
and forty were gathered. The main army under St. Clair had taken a circuitous
march to join General Schuyler at Fort Edwart,
via Rutland, Dorset and Arlington, arriving there the 12th.
Now all was consternation through the State, many of the inhabitants on the east
side of the mountain leaving their homes and crossing the Connecticut River into
New Mampshire and Massachusetts, and great numbers on the west side, especially
of towns north of Bennington, were thrown into a quandary as to what course to
take, from fear begotten of the proclamation of Burgoyne, "of destruction to the
lives and property of all who should oppose him, but promising protection and
security to those who should give him their adhesion, and offering payment 'in
solid coin' for all provisions that should be brought to his camp." To very many
the large and well equipped army of Burgoyne seemed irresistible. Great numbers
repaired to Colonel Skene, "who was at Castleton, and took the oath of
allegiance to the king, many of whom, joining the invading army, took up arms
against their country." The more patriotic disclaiming obedience to the enemy's
demands, abandoned their homes, and, taking what they could carry with them,
fled to the south, some stopping in Bennington, but most going through to
friends in Berkshire county and so on to Connecticut. Thus the territory lying
between Bennington and the Hudson, being in the course "of Burgoyne towards
Albany, was made, in effect, an enemy's country, and Bennington became a
frontier town."
Messages were sent out from the Council of Safety to New Hampshire and
Massachusetts asking for immediate aid. An attack being expected at Manchester,
the force there under Colonel Warner was increased by all of the militia that
could be collected; and to sustain a patrol for protection against the Tories in
their midst, and to guard the frontiers from unexpected attacks, "the council
ordered the property of those of their inhabitants that had joined the enemy to
be sequestered and sold." Thus a fund was secured to help in organizing a
regiment of rangers under the command of Colonel Samuel Herrick of Bennington,
which was of great service to the country.
The Assembly of New Hampshire instantly responded to the message of the Vermont
council, and ordered a brigade of their militia to be placed under the command
of General John Stark, who had served in the first French war, as colonel at
Bunker Hill, in Canada, and under Washington at Trenton and Princeton. He had
resigned his commission and retired from the Continental service, as Congress
had promoted junior officers over him, and, as he felt, unworthily.
Now, by instructions from the president of New Hampshire, he "was to repair to
Charlestown, No. 4," and when the troops were collected there "to take command
of them and march into the State of Vermont, and there act in conjunction with
the troops of that State, or any other of the States, or of the United States,
or separately, as it should appear expedient to him, for the protection of the
people or the annoyance of the enemy." Stark with his men arrived at Manchester
August 7th, when he dechned to march his troops to the Hudson to join those of
General Schuyler on the ground of the defenseless condition in which it would
leave the inhabitants, and that he could do more to perplex the advance of
Burgoyne and harass him upon his flanks than by joining the main army under him.
With Colonel Warner, the remnant of "whose Continental regiment was left at
Manchester under the command of Lieutenant Colonel Samuel Safford, he and his
men passed on to Bennington, arriving on the 9th, having learned that a large
body of the enemy which for some time had been at Castleton, threatening
Manchester, and to cross over to Connecticut River, had marched to the Hudson.
General Stark encamped for a few days about two miles west of Bennington Center,
near the then residence of Colonel Herrick, collecting information with regard
to the designs of the enemy by scouts sent into their lines, advising with the
Council of Safety and with Colonel Warner, who was better acquainted with the
arts and situation of the foe, perhaps, than any other man, and aiding by every
means at his or his associate's command to hurry towards Bennington the troops
from Massachusetts and Connecticut for the coming conflict, which now seemed
imminent.
The advance of Burgoyne towards Albany, on account of the natural difficulties
of the way and the opposition he encountered, was tardy, and when he reached the
Hudson River he was "so deficient in provisions and also in cattle and carriages
for transportation that he was much embarrassed about the means for advancing
further." For the purpose of supplying himself with these things, which he
learned had been collected in considerable quantities at Bennington for the
supply of the American forces, he resolved to seize them
for his own army." The command was given to Lieutenant-Colonel Baum, a veteran
German otficer, whose forces numbered some seven hundred, consisting of
"dismounted dragoons," "Frazer's marksmen," "Canadian volunteers," "Provincials
or Tories," with one hundred Indians, and two light pieces of cannon. He left
Burgoyne's camp, near Saratoga, arriving at Cambridge on the 13th of August. On
the morning of the 14th he had reached Sancoick, about half a mile below North
Hoosick, where he routed a party of Americans who were in possession of a mill.
It was here upon the head of a barrel he wrote back to Burgoyne "by five
prisoners taken here they agree that 1,500 to 1,800 men are at Bennington, but
are supposed to leave on our approach." They did leave on his approach, but not
in the direction he had anticipated. The old mill is still standing, and is
about eight miles from Bennington.
Stark having received information by scouts on the 13th that a party of Indians
was at Cambridge, had sent Colonel Gregg with two hundred men to oppose them,
and hearing still later that a still larger body of troops with artillery was
advancing on Bennington he had "sent to Manchester for Colonel Warner's regiment
and the neighboring militia to rally to his support." He started with his
brigade to meet the foe, accompanied by Colonels Warner, Williams, Ilerrick and
Brush, on the morning of the 14th, and had gone about five miles when he met
Gregg retreating from Saucoick, closely followed by the enemy. Stark's men were
formed in order of battle, but no engagement took place, as he considered his
position unfavorable for a general encounter. He fell back about a mile and
encamped on the farm now owned by Lewis Northouse, on the hill near the dwelling
recently erected by him. Baum halted his forces on the west side of the
Walloomsac River, and stationed the greater part of his German veterans, under
his own command, on the top of a thickly wooded hill, northwest of Stark's
encampment, where the shore rises abruptly three or four hundred feet, his
position overlooking the country around. Here he constructed intrenchmcnts of
earth and logs to protect himself from attack on the west and his flanks, the
bank of the river on the east securing him from annoyance in that direction.
The road runs westerly across the river at the south end of this high bank,
and the bridge was an important pass. For its defense Baum threw up a breastwork
on the high bank of the river above it, upon which was placed one
of the cannon, and on both sides of the road smaller breastworks were erected
near the west end of the bridge, which were manned by Frazer's marksmen,
and other preparations were made for strengthening the position. Quite a number
of Tories had joined Baum on his march and were under Colonel Francis Pfister, a British officer of wealth and influence, living near what is now
known as Hoosick Corners. "These with most of Peters's corps of loyalists,
were posted on a hill east of the stream, forty or fifty rods to the southeast
of
the bridge." Strong works of defense known as the "Tory breastworks," were
erected here, and the position would have the protection of ball and grape from
the cannon at the bridge. The other cannon in charge of German grenadiers,
supported by some Tories, appears to have been placed further to the west in
a cleared field near the road on the hillside which commanded the approaches
to the bridge and the Tory encampment, and also to the south flank of Baum's
encampment." "The positions of the two hostile bodies though but about two miles
apart, were entirely hidden from each other by a heavily wooded intervening hill."
"The force under General Stark was composed of the greater part of his brigade of New Hampshire militia, a small number of Vermont militia from the east
side of the mountain under Colonel William Williams, who had been stationed
at Manchester, Colonel Herrick's corps of rangers then forming, the State militia from Bennington and its vicinity under Colonel Nathaniel Brush, of which
there were two companies from Bennington, one commanded by Captain Samuel Robinson and the other by Captain Elijah Dewey; and on the morning of
the l6th Stark was joined by Colonel Simonds and some militia from Berkshire county. On the night of the 14th, after ascertaining the position of the
enemy, Stark called a council consisting, "of the leading members of the
Council
of Safety, as well as Colonels Warner and Hcrrick and other military officers,
in which a plan for attacking the enemy was discussed and adopted, and it was
agreed that the attack should be made the next morning, but the 15th was
so excessively rainy as to prevent any attempt at a general action. Scouts were,
however, sent out, some of which were engaged in successful skirmishes."
The plan arranged for the 16th was for Colonel Nichols with two hundred
men, afterwards increased to three hundred, to make a wide northern circuit
and come upon the rear of Baum's left, and Colonel Herrick with three hundred men made up of Colonel
Brush's militia and his rangers, taking a wide
southern circuit to get upon the rear of his right, both as speedily and stealthily as possible. "Colonels Hubbard and Stickney with three hundred of Stark's
brigade, were ordered to the enemy's extreme right." The attention of the
enemy was taken up during the time occupied by the three parties in gaining
their different positions by menacing assaults on his front, or, as Thomas Mellen, a New Hampshire veteran said, "we
were marched round and round a circular hill till we were tired, and Stark said it was to amuse the Germans." It
was about three o'clock when firing was commenced by Nichols's men. which
was the signal for a general attack. The firing was immediately followed by
the troops under Herrick and the third detachment of Hubbard and Stickney's,
while General Stark "with his reserve of New Hampshire men and the Berkshire and some Vermont militia, in the face of the enemy's cannon assailed the
Tory breastwork and the pass of the bridge in front. The engagement thus
became general and lasted," says Stark in his report to Gates, "two hours, and
was the hottest I ever saw; it represented one continued clap of thunder." The
Indians, alarmed at the prospect of being inclosed between the parties of Nichols and Herrick, fled at the beginning of the fight, but
Baum, with his Germans and all others under his command, having the advantage of
their position behind the intrenchments which the rain of the 15th had given them ample time
to erect and make strong, fought with great resolution and bravery, but they
were overpowered by their militia assailants, and either fled or surrendered
prisoners of war.
The prisoners having been sent away to Bennington, the militia naturally
scattered in collecting the spoils, and viewing the work which had been accomplished. Soon it was learned that reinforcements were within a distance of two
miles. They had been sent forward under the command of Colonel Breyman
numbering six hundred and forty-two, all Germans, "with two pieces of cannon which Burgoyne, on hearing that the force at Bennington was greater than
had been expected, had dispatched to the assistance of Baum." It was no easy
matter to check the progress of these veteran soldiers, as Stark's men were in
great confusion, but "happily at this juncture Warner's regiment of about one
hundred and forty men came up fresh under Lieutenant-Colonel Safford, and
took its position in front, serving as a rallying point for the scattered
militia."
Breyman advanced with his two pieces of artillery with infantry on either
side until he was met by a body of the militia which had been collected and a
stand made forty or fifty rods east of the present Walloomsac Depot. "Here
he was attacked in front and flank, a most deadly fire being poured into his
ranks from a wooded hill on his left. The action was very severe and continued till after sunset, when many of Breyman's men being killed or wounded
and his artillery horses shot down he abandoned his cannon and fled. General Stark pursued his flying forces till the approaching darkness rendered it
necessary to draw off his men to prevent their firing upon each other. "With
one hour more of daylight," says Stark in his official report, "we should have
captured the whole body." He further says, "we recovered four pieces of brass
cannon, seven hundred stand of arms and brass banded drums, several Hessian swords, about seven hundred prisoners, two hundred and seven dead on
the spot, the number of wounded is yet unknown. That part of the enemy
that made their escape marched all night and were returned to our camp. Our
loss was inconsiderable, about forty wounded and thirty killed."
The report of musketry and cannon was distinctly heard in the center of the
town, and the old village was filled with women and children whose husbands
and fathers were on the battlefield in deadly conflict with the enemy. The
anxiety and dreadful suspense of that long day cannot be realized, and much
less described; but a flood of gratitude and joy burst forth as the news came
that the foe had been defeated and a glorious victory won. Bennington, indeed, was called to deeply mourn, for among the killed were four of its most
respected citizens, viz.: "John Fay, a son of Stephen, Henry Walbridge, brother
of Ebenezer, Daniel Warner, cousin of the colonel, and Nathan Clarke, son of
Nathan, and brother of Isaac. They were all in the prime of life, and all heads
of families, leaving widows and children to mourn their sudden bereavement.
The grief for their loss was not confined to their immediate relatives, but was
general and sincere." Colonel Baum was mortally wounded as was also Colonel Pfister and both were taken prisoners to a house about a mile distant in
Shaftsbury, opposite the present paper-mill of C. E. Welling. They both died
in this house within a day or two, which was taken down in 186l, and were buried on the bank of the river near by, though the particular spot is not known.
The victory is justly pronounced by Bancroft as "one of most brilliant and
eventful of the war;" another says, "the current of success was at once turned
from the British to the American arms;" another, "the fate of Burgoyne and
his army was, in effect, sealed at Bennington, and his final capture well
assured." "General Washington, on being informed of the event, considered it as
deciding the fate of Burgoyne, and dismissed all anxiety about his invasion." Its
effect upon the enemy was most depressing. "Four days after the battle Burgoyne wrote to the British minister a letter marked 'private,'" in which he says
of it, that "had I succeeded, I should have formed a junction with St. Leger
and been now in Albany."
https://archive.org/details/historyofbenning1889aldr/page/n547/mode/2up
Next to General Stark Colonel Warner should receive the highest credit for the
result of the day, though Colonel Hcrrick and all the officers and men deserved high praise for the adroitness and valor they exhibited in the various
attacks and repulses. Warner's experience in the Continental army, and his
acquaintance with the country and positions occupied by the enemy, well prepared him for "Stark's chief adviser in planning the attack on the enemy." On
the 17th of October following, Burgoyne, from the crippled condition of his
forces and the scanty means of supply for his men, mainly brought about by
this battle, was obliged to surrender with his army as prisoners of war to the
American forces at Saratoga.
"Copy of Captain Samuel Robinson's roll, August 16, 1777. — Were in battle Robert Cochran, Gideon Spencer, William
Henry, Henry Walbridge, Rufus
Branch, John Larned, Thomas Abel, Nathan Lawrence, Josiah Brush, David
Fay (Fifer), Leonard Robinson, Daniel Biddlecome, Levi Hatheway, Abram Hatheway, Reuben Colvin, Eliphalet Stickney, Daniel Rude,
Benjamin Holmes,
James Marivater, Mr. Alger, Annice Fuller, Jonah Brewster, George Dale, John
Marble, Ephraim Marble, Aaron Hubbell, Samuel Safford, jr., Aaron Smith,
Ephraim Smith, Samuel Henry, Edward Henderson, Jonathan Haynes, ArchelausTupper, Daniel Warner, Lieutenant Simon Hatheway, Aaron Miller, John
Fay, Elijah Fay, Joseph Fay, John Clark, Jehosephat Holmes, Moses Rice, Benjamin Whipple, jr., Silas Robinson, John Weeks, Moses Scott, Alpheus
Hathaway, Solomon Walbridge, Ebenezer Brocket, Jehiel Smith, Asa Branch,
Phinehas Wright, John Smith, Jesse Belknap, Silvanus Brown, John Forbes, Stephen Williams, William Post, David Safford, Jared Post, Jeremiah Bingham,
Samuel Slocum, Josiah Hurd, Elijah Brewster, Solomon Leason, Thomas Selden, John Rigney, Elisha Smith, Solomon Safford, Joseph Roe, William Terrill,
Noah Beach, Simeon Sears, David Robinson, Joseph Safford, Isaac Webster."
There were still more than five years of war with England to be endured, a
period longer than the war of the late rebellion, and with the enemy in
possession of Lake Champlain; with the jealousy and rapacity of the New York government, which still envied and claimed our possessions, together with the Tory
element to contend with, which ever and anon showed its "hydra head," "the
inhabitants of Bennington and its vicinity were kept in a state of almost continual apprehension and alarm."
The Legislature of the State as already organized, was to meet at Bennington on the 4th of June, 1778. A few days before the time Colonel Ethan
Allen who had been a prisoner in England over two years returned to Bennington. He was received with much rejoicing; among other demonstrations
cannon was fired amid shouting by the large numbers who had gathered to
greet him. Just at this time there was great excitement over the conviction
of David Redding, a Tory, who had been tried for giving comfort to the enemy
on the lake, and for secretly appropriating "for the use of the Tories a number
of guns from the house of David Robinson, where they had been lodged for
safe keeping." He had been sentenced to be hung on the 4th of June, but it was
shown to the governor and council, then met, that he had been tried by
six jurors only, and the council granted a reprieve until the next Thursday at
two o'clock in thc afternoon. A large number had gathered to witness the
execution, and were anxious to see it consummated. They were afraid something might occur to hinder the carrying out of the sentence, and there
were
indications that the people, perhaps, would take the case into their own hands;
"whereupon Ethan Allen, suddenly pressing through the crowd, mounted a stump and
waving his hat, exclaiming 'attention, the whole' proceeded to announce the reason for the reprieve, advised the multitude to depart peacebly
to their homes and return the day fixed for the execution in the act of the
governor and council, adding with an oath, 'you sh.all see somebody hung at
all
events, for if Redding is not hung I will be hung myself.' Upon this assurance
the uproar ceased and the crowd dispersed." Redding was tried and convicted
on the 9th by a jury of twelve, and his execution took place on the 11th of
June, the time to which the reprieve extendetl. "The place of execution was
in a field west of the road and opposite the tavern-house of Landlord Fay,'"
a little north of the "Governor Tichenor" place, now occupied by Mrs. George
Lyman.
There has been but one other public execution in Bennington. Archibald
C. Bates of Shaftsbury, was hung on the 8th of February, 1839 for the murder of
his brother's wife in the preceding month of October. He shot and instantly killed her while she was holding a babe in her arms, of which crime he
was convicted and afterwards confessed it. The nurse, with the little child of
the murdered woman, was early upon the ground that she might witness the
whole proceedings. The gallows stood in the lot on the west side of the road
in Bennington Center, a little north of where the battle monument stands.
That order and decorum in the fulfillment of the law should be maintained in
every respect the militia were called out, commanded by Colonel John L. Potter of Pownal, Captain William E. Hawks of North Bennington taking charge
of the procession. The gallows was erected by or under the direction of Benjamin R. Sears, and the fatal drop was in charge of the county sheriff, Gurdon
H. Smith of Manchester, who discharged his duty with singular conscientiousness as a punishment necessary to be inflicted rather than an official act which
would bring notoriety. There was no flaw or interruption in the arrangements, and at the appointed hour, with little or no sign to give warning to the
multitude, the execution was effected, many witnessing it who had made up
their minds to close their eyes at the moment and others were disappointed
that they were looking at the time in another direction. Rev. E. W. Hooker, D.
D. had often visited the prisoner in his cell for prayer and to impart spiritual advice. The prayer upon the gallows was made by the Rev. Mr. Hubbard
of the Methodist Church, whose voice could be heard, it is said, the distance
of more than a mile. Pubhc sentiment has so changed with reference to executions of this kind that they are now witnessed only by the proper officials,
and enough of those particularly interested to render it sure the law has been
duly enforced.
Aldrich, Lewis Cass, editor; History
of Bennington County, Vt. ©
1889, pages 265-275
.