My great-grandfather brought his family from Chattooga County, Georgia in the late 1890s to settle in Gunter.  He and my great-grandmother are buried now at Tioga Cemetery : J. L. (Jeremiah Levi) Davis and Mrs. L. M. (Lettie Matilda nee Johnson) Davis
 
I believe they belonged to the Tioga Primitive Baptist Church.  It is possible that this family were members there too.