Lake County Ohio GenWeb

Index to Justice of the Peace Criminal Docket, Lake County, Ohio, 1875-1894

State of Ohio, Lake County. Justice's Court for Willoughby Township. These are cases before W. A. Lilly, Justice of the Peace for Willoughby Township until February 1887 when Justice Charles J. Komar took over. The work begins in June of 1875 and continues to August 1894. There is a very occassional substitute for the J. P. The book consists of about 321 pages, some of them blank. There is an index, though not complete at the end of the book. There are 254 indexed entries, with some names repeated. The information found there includes name of offender, offense charged, others involved, witnesses, etc., the decision made and fees for the case. The index includes the date, page, defendant, complainant and a brief mention of the charge. Some of these defendants were acquitted. Not all names of victims were put in this index.


The handwriting is not always distinguishable, so there may be other interpretations of names. Widely browsing the list is suggested. Always consult the "original" for much more case detail.


The volume is kept by the Clerk of Courts in Common Pleas, 25 N. Park Place, Painesville, Ohio. It is digitized and is found on their site under "Historical Naturalization Records" https://recordroom.cottsystems.com/lakeoh/guest/search/oib On the right side, the top search engine is for index books and cards. The search engine below that is for unindexed records, where this will be found.


This volume was indexed by Margaret Frank.


Lake County, Ohio, "Justice of the Peace Criminal Docket," Lake County,1889-1894, held by Clerk of Courts, Painesville, Ohio; digital images at Clerk of Courts' Website (https://recordroom.cottsystems.com/lakeoh/guest/search/oib : accessed 30 August 2021).


Image Date Defendant Complainant Type of Case
43 22 Mar 1878 Ackerman, Charles Waite, Clinton Unlawful Fishing
196 3 May 1890 Babcock, Dan F Barnes, James M Unlawful Killing of Bird
176 13 Mar 1889 Barnes, Harry Dunlap, John Assault
209 7 Apr 1891 Barnes, James M Lee, Eugene Assault
180 15 Jul 1889 Barnes, James N Briskey, Nicholas Assault
220 14 Sep 1891 Bentley, Daniel Steinhardt, Henry Assault
206 14 Jan 1891 Berbin, Harrison Jr. Barnes, James M. Unlawful Hunting of Rabbits
308 2 Aug 1894 Billson, Alma Whitright, Hattie for Lena Assault
98 24 Jul 1883 Bilson, Frank Abell, George Assault & Battery
143 6 Oct 1887 Bilson, Frank Jackson, G H Theft
46 15 Apr 1878 Bilson, George Barbarich, John Unlawful Assembly/ Damage to Property
98 24 Jul 1883 Bilson, Henry Abell, George Assault & Battery
98 24 Jul 1883 Bilson, Peter Abell, George Assault & Battery
256 12 Dec 1892 Bromeley, Charles Vogtler, Louis Assault & Ravish
226 15 Dec 1891 Bromley, Charles Vogtler, Louis Assault
124 27 Dec 1884 Brown, Hosmer, Brown, J B Assault
218 9 Sep 1891 Burgess, Charles W Evill, Thomas B Assault
5 14 Aug 1875 Burnett, D Houliston, George F Assault & Battery
84 12 Apr 1881 Callahan, William Rutland, Alfred Petit Larceny
77 15 Oct 1880 Callender, Allen Rockafellow, Samuel R Assault & Battery
77 15 Oct 1880 Callender, Ed Rockafellow, Samuel R Assault & Battery
146 30 Nov 1887 Campbell, Fred McCall, Arthur C Theft
244 18 Jun 1892 Campbell, John Barnes, J M Unlawful Fishing
21 8 May 1876 Cassell, Douglas P Ballantine, Thomas M Unlawfully Set Fire to Barn
20 27 Apr 1876 Cassell, Fred Earle, Olive Assault & Battery
120 15 Oct 1884 Chapman, John Chapman, Hiram Threat of Assault
132 26 Feb 1887 Clark, Derwood Law, David for Eugene Fowler Attempt to Kill
292 25 Dec 1893 Covert, Chancy Lloyd, William Boundary Dispute? Cutting Timber
224 27 Oct 1891 Covert, Charny Barnes, James M Unlawful Fishing
114 14 Jun 1884 Cox, Sam Kennedy, Ransom Theft
203 12 Dec 1890 Crow, Malaca Stevens, Henry K Unlawful Selling of Liquor to George Brown Jr.
276 10 Jul 1893 Custin, W G McWithy Andrew Assault
246 25 Jun 1892 Dawson, Henry C Jones, Felix Unlawfully Open on Sunday
136 4 May 1887 Doe, John (Name Unknown) Boyce, Joseph H and Julia Theft
164 26 Aug 1888 Doe, John (Unk Italian) Shehan, Thomas Assault
118 23 Sep 1884 Dunlap, William Morgan, G W Unlawful Gambling
304 30 Apr 1894 Eddy, Stanley Payne, Luther D Assault
25 11 May 1876 Ellen, J G Ballantine, Thomas M Unlawfully Set Fire to Barn
37 1 May 1877 Elliott, Frederick Butter, John Assault & Battery
86 27 May 1881 Ely, Jacob Ridward, James A Assault & Battery
194 19 Apr 1890 Enshoff, Earnest Barnes, James M Unlawful Fishing
56 6 Jun 1879 Feisler, Louis Stray, Michael Breaking & Entering
224 27 Oct 1891 Fowler, Charles Barnes, James M Unlawful Fishing
236 16 Jun 1892 Fowler, Charles Barnes, James Unlawful Fishing
250 27 Oct 1892 Fowler, Charles Barnes, James M Unlawfully Shot Birds
292 25 Dec 1893 Fowler, Charlie Lloyd, William Boundary Dispute? Cutting Timber
143 6 Oct 1887 Fowler, F F Jackson, G H Theft
240 16 Jun 1892 Fowler, Welden Barnes, J M Unlawful Fishing
278 17 Jul 1893 Fuller, Dick aka Fuller, Chany Horton, John Assault
248 5 Jul 1892 Galuska, William Elliott, Israel Assault
148 23 Apr 1888 Gherkins, James Thackwell, William Assault & Battery
110 29 Mar 1884 Gilson, Franklin M Cox, John C Theft
96 22 May 1883 Gunn, Frank B Elliott, May E Assault
106 18 Dec 1883 Hall, Emma Haver, Nellie E Threat of Assault
274 26 Jun 1893 Hare, A Brown, James B Assault
262 26 Apr 1893 Harmon, John McCann, James Assault
264 20 May 1893 Harmon, John Clark, William Assault
198 12 May 1890 Harris, Eugene Malkin, Joseph Assault
112 31 May 1884 Hart, Frank Holt, Jennie A Assault, rape
60 22 Jul 1879 Hastings, John Dunlap, Johnny Assault & Battery
10 7 Jan 1876 Haver, Jay Wellner, George Theft
284 12 Oct 1893 Hayden, Charles Hayden, Mary Ann Assault
152 23 May 1888 Heariman, Frank Gough, James Using House for Prostitution
152 23 May 1888 Heariman, Mary Gough, James Using House for Prostitution
170 15 Nov 1888 Higginling, Albert Viall, S W Theft
26 27 May 1876 Higgins, Andrew M Higgins, Delia M Assault
288 1 Nov 1893 Hill, Joseph Jones, Felix Assault
35 13 Aug 1876 Hitt, Frank Woodford, William Theft
81 21 Mar 1881 Hitt, Frank Stevens, Ezrin C selling liquor to alcoholic
163 27 Jul 1888 Holt, Henry I Sanborn, Dan M Erecting a Pigpen, Noxious to Health
186 11 Jan 1890 Hubbard, Charles Granger, Horace Theft
186 11 Jan 1890 Hubbard, George Granger, Horace Theft
43 22 Mar 1878 Husselton, George Waite, Clinton Unlawful Fishing
104 31 Aug 1883 Hutchins, Albert Wilson, Andrew J Threat of Assault
90 12 Aug 1882 Ingram, Frances Goucher, John Assault
170 15 Nov 1888 Jenkins, Benjamin Viall, S W Theft
213 8 Apr 1891 Jennison, Major White, Milton Assault
46 15 Apr 1878 Judd, Carson Barbarich, John Unlawful Assembly/ Damage to Property
302 9 Apr 1894 Jukes, John A Furlory, Edward; Margaret and Maynard Assault
258 13 Nov 1893 King, Charles Campbell, Henry Theft
35 13 Aug 1876 Kingsland, Oscar Woodford, William Theft
192 19 Apr 1890 Kirchamer, John Barnes, James M Unlawful Fishing
108 23 Feb 1884 La Schay, Henry Anderson, Charles Suspect of Theft
160 26 Jul 1888 Lamareux, Helen Devinen, Mary Assault
234 16 Jun 1892 Law, George F Barnes, James Unlawful Fishing
30 30 Jul 1876 Lloyd, Reuben Hammond, Mark Assault & Battery
252 9 Sep 1892 Lloyd, William Woodford, William Assault
260 2 Apr 1893 Long, Harry Mahon, John W Unlawful Fishing
206 14 Jan 1891 Lynch, Patrick Barnes, James M. Unlawful Hunting of Rabbits
102 2 Aug 1883 Mahon, Mike McMahon, Maria Assault & Battery
74 21 Aug 1880 Malony, William White, Milton Assault
230 20 Feb 1892 Martin, Seth Crobaugh, William Threat of Assault
292 25 Dec 1893 McGuner, Douglas Lloyd, William Boundary Dispute? Cutting Timber
122 24 Nov 1884 McMahon, Mike Hughes, Benjamin Assault
19 4 Apr 1876 McQuinn, John Hammond, Mark Theft
290 8 Nov 1893 Minandes, Salvator Cristofor, Louis Assault
84 12 Apr 1881 Mulhall, Charles Rutland, Alfred Petit Larceny
15 29 Mar 1876 Murphy, John White, O F Theft
126 16 Jan 1885 Myers, John Sprague, Freddie Assault & Battery
46 15 Apr 1878 Nash, Homer Barbarich, John Unlawful Assembly/ Damage to Property
280 21 Sep 1893 Northcote, William Granger, Horan C Theft
156 18 Jun 1888 Nye, John Marble, Leonard Assault & Battery
156 18 Jun 1888 Nye, Milo Marble, Leonard Assault & Battery
128 18 Dec 1885 O'Connel, Thomas O'Connel, Mary Assault
139 14 Sep 1887 O'Connell, Thomas Grover, Hectar C Assault
10 7 Jan 1876 Odine, Jacob Wellner, George Theft
282 4 Oct 1893 Pellett, Reuben Reeve, Eugene I Theft
50 3 Jun 1878 Perkins, W C Frith, William Assault & Battery
46 15 Apr 1878 Potter, Plinn Barbarich, John Unlawful Assembly/ Damage to Property
71 21 Jul 1880 Reeve, Alvin Kelley, James W Assault & Battery
206 14 Jan 1891 Reiber, Walter Barnes, James M. Unlawful Hunting of Rabbits
200 12 Dec 1890 Rice, Benjamin Stevens, Henry K Unlawful Selling of Liquor
242 17 Jun 1892 Richardson, Burgess H Barnes, J M Unlawful Fishing
67 6 Jan 1880 Richardson, Charles Baker, Nealy Assault & Battery
64 1 Jan 1880 Roper, John Steven, Henry R Assault & Battery
53 18 Sep 1878 Ruff, Fred Morley, Charles T Resisting Officer, assault
174 6 Mar 1889 Rush, Orin Pettis, William N Assault
116 4 Sep 1884 Ryan, Frank Radcliff, Robert Petit Larceny
216 3 Sep 1891 Ryan, Joseph Flickenger, Elam E Assault
298 2 Apr 1894 Saude, William Anderson, Otto Assault with Knife
58 9 Jun 1879 Saxton, Lucius Jr Clark, Nathan Assault & Battery
286 13 Oct 1893 Shaffer, Edward Metz, Stephen Assault
190 19 Apr 1890 Shaffer, John Barnes, James M Unlawful Fishing
254 15 Sep 1892 Sherman, George Covert, Margaret Fraud
80 24 Feb 1881 St John, T C Stevens, Henry R Assault
3 3 Jul 1875 Stevens, Henry R Hurd, A D Unlawful Horseracing
40 1 Dec 1877 Stevens, Henry R Myers, James Assault & Battery
94 18 Aug 1882 Steveson, Nev. Wagner, William Assault
17 1 Apr 1876 Stewart, Gilbert Stewart, Joseph Assault
141 24 Sept 1887 Stewart, Gilbert Short, James S Assault
52 31 Jul 1878 Stewart, James Unlawful Attachment to RR Car
86 27 May 1881 Stray, Frank Ridward, James A Assault & Battery
69 4 Jun 1880 Thackwell, William Chapin, William A Assault & Battery
82 24 Mar 1881 Thackwell, William Ruder, George Assault & Battery
88 28 Jun 1882 Thomas, William Viall, S W & J W Fraud
1 7 Jun 1875 Van Luven, Lewis Saxton, Lucius Assault & Battery
62 17 Nov 1879 Vanleuvan, Schluyler Roberts, Ransom R Assault & Murder threat
270 8 Jun 1893 VanLuven, Elmer Barnes, James Unlawful Fishing
270 8 Jun 1893 VanLuven, Emery Barnes, James Unlawful Fishing
232 15 Jun 1892 VanLuven, Herbert Barnes, James Unlawful Spear Fishing
166 17 Sep 1888 Voegtler, Louis Prescott, Charles H Assault
92 16 Aug 1882 Wagner, William Steveson, Nev Assault
86 27 May 1881 Warren, Charles Ridward, James A Assault & Battery
13 9 Mar 1876 Warren, Ed Tryon, James H Theft
13 9 Mar 1876 Warren, Henry Tryon, James H Theft
228 16 Feb 1892 Weishout, George Woodford, Charles Assault
306 6 May 1894 White, Joseph Payne, Luther D Assault
238 16 Jun 1892 Whitright, Allen Barnes, James Unlawful Fishing
292 25 Dec 1893 Willis, Julius Lloyd, William Boundary Dispute? Cutting Timber
292 25 Dec 1893 Willis, Lucius Sen. Lloyd, William Boundary Dispute? Cutting Timber
7 31 Aug 1875 Wilson, John Woodford, William Theft
268 9 Jun 1893 Wood, Alford Barnes, James M Unlawful Fishing
270 8 Jun 1893 Wood, Alford Barnes, James Unlawful Fishing
178 27 May 1889 Wood, George James, John Assault

Return to the Government Page

Back to Lake OHGenWeb

Please note:

If you have other Lake County resources or corrections please contact the webmaster at CynthiaGenWeb@gmail.com

Page created 29 August 2021 and last updated 29 August 2021.

© 2021 Cynthia Turk, Lake County, Ohio GenWeb