Seward County, Nebraska Churches
Congregational, Methodist, Lutheran and Catholic were the earliest denominations to organize in the county. After the initial push, however, the Congregational churches seemed to fade, giving way to the latter three. Another thing to keep in mind is the evolution of the demonination itself. As an example, the Methodists started out as Methodist Episcopal. In the early 1900s, it became the Methodist Church. In the 1960s, a merger with the Evangelical United Brethern, changed the name to United Methodist Church. In the Lutheran church, new synods have formed changing the organizational and theological structure of a congregation. As for record keeping, some denominations are better than others. Lutheran, Catholic and Episcopal churches probably keep the best records. Generally, Seward County has several areas that are predominately one religion. The northeastern part of the county has a strong Catholic presence. Lutherans are the major denomination in Seward and the western part of the county. A number of the Lutheran churches, both town and rural, have and had schools. The Milford area has a number of Mennonite congregations. Methodists have churches in Utica, Beaver Crossing, Seward and Milford. To serve rural congregations, in the early days of the county when roads were less than ideal, there were a number of rural churches serving localities. While there are still a couple, most congregations have either consolidated or disbanded. The following table lists most of the congregations in Seward County. The first column is the location - town or rural. The second column is the name/denomination of the church. The third column is the year of organization, if known. The fourth column includes notes about the church. The fifth column lists whether the church is active or has disbanded.
Location
Name/denomination
Date of Organization
Notes
Status
Beaver Crossing
Sacred Heart Catholic
1890 Constructed a church
Active
Beaver Crossing
Christian Church
1882
Organized with the help of the Nebraska Christian
Missionary Society. In 1883 the congregation moved
to Walnut Creek. The Walnut Creek church
was moved back to Beaver Crossing. It is now
Disciples of Christ.Active
Beaver Crossing
Zion Evangelical Church
1882
It combined with other churches in 1885 and formed
the Friendly Mission. In 1946, it affiliated with the
Evangelical United Brethern. In 1963,
it merged with the Methodist Church.Active, Methodist
Beaver Crossing
United Evangelical Church
1890
Disbanded about 1903
Beaver Crossing
United Methodist Church
1888
It organized as the Methodist Episcopal Church. In 1963, it
merged with the Friendly Mission.Active
Beaver Crossing
The Little White Church
1978
The church is now known as Beaver Crossing Christian
Fellowship Church.Active
Beaver Crossing
Congregational
1871
Closed about ten years later in 1881.
Disbanded
Bee
St. Wenceslaus Catholic
Church built in 1910
Active
Bee
Evangelical United Brethern
1889
Joined Seward congregation.
Disbanded
Cordova
St. Johns Lutheran
1883
Active
Cordova
Our Savior's Danish
Evangelical Lutheran (UELC)1883
1960 merged with St. John's Evangelical Lutheran
to form Trinity Lutheran.Active as Trinity Lutheran.
Cordova
St. John's Danish
Evangelical Lutheran (AELC)1894
In 1894 a group left the original church over
theological differences. In
1901, the new name was adopted. In 1960, the
congregation merged with St. John's to form
Trinity Lutheran Church. St. John's records from
1889-1954 are on microfilm at the Nebraska
State Historical Society in Lincoln.Active as Trinity Lutheran.
Garland
Zion Lutheran
1886
Active
Garland/Germantown
Congregational Church
Abt. 1893
The record book has be microfilmed and can be
found at the Nebraska State Historical
Society in Lincoln.Disbanded abt. 1915
Goehner
Holy Cross Lutheran
1933
UAC/LCMS
Active
Goehner
United Church of Christ
1902
Also known as Friedens United Church of
Christ. It was formed to serve the German
speaking community and affiliated with
Evangelical Synod of North America. Denomination
mergers brought it into the United Church
of Christ fold in 1957. Records from 1902-1974
have been microfilmed and can be found at the
Nebraska State Historical Society in Lincoln.Active
Goehner
St. John's Lutheran
1897
Disbanded 1922
Johnson Creek
Fresers Danske Evangeliske
Luthrska MenighedOrganized about 1880.
Microfilmed records can be found at the
Nebraska State Historical Society in Lincoln.Disbanded about 1932.
Marysville
Zion Evangelical Lutheran Church
1870
Located about 3 1/2 miles west of Staplehurst
on Lincoln Creek, it merged to form Our Redeemer Lutheran
Church in Staplehurst in about 1966. Microfilm records,
1872-1970, can be found at the Nebraska State
Historical Society in Lincoln.Active as Our Redeemer.
Milford
East Fairview Mennonite Church
1875
Active
Milford
Milford Mennonite Church
1925
Organized as Amish Mennonite Church. The name
was changed in 1955.Active
Milford
Beth-el Mennonite Church
1959
Active
Milford
United Methodist Church
1874
1968 the Milford Methodist Church and the Evangelical
United Brethern Churches merged to form the
Milford UMC.Active
Milford
Emmanuel Evangelical Church
1880
Merged with Zion Evangelical Church in 1922 to
form Immanuel Evangelical Church. In 1946, the
United Brethern Church and the Evangelical Church
merged to form the Evangelical United Brethern (EUB)
Church. In 1968, the EUB and Methodist Churches merged
to become the Milford United Methodist Church (UMC).Active as Milford UMC.
Milford
Zion Evangelical Church
1880
Located five miles northeast of Milford, Zion merged
with Emmanuel Evangelical Church in 1922. See above.Active as Milford UMC.
Milford
Bellwood Mennonite Church
1957
The congregation was organized in Beaver Crossing,
but built in the Milford area the following year.Active
Milford
Milford Missionary Church
1890
The congregation was officially organized in 1894
as Pleasant View Mennonite Brethern in Christ and
located three miles west and two miles south of
Milford near Pleasant View School. In 1918, the
congregation moved into Milford. The name was changed in
1947 to United Missionary Church. The current name
was adopted in 1969.Active
Milford
United Church of Christ, Milford
1874
It was organized as Evanglische Friedens Gemeinde
am West Blue - Peace Evangelical Congregation of
West Blue. Microfilm records, 1874-1970, can be
found at the Nebraska State Historical Society
in Lincoln.Disbanded
Milford
First Congregational Church
1869
Microfilmed records, 1874-1959, can be found at the
Nebraska State Historical Society in Lincoln.Disbanded
Milford
Assembly of God
Active
Milford
Good Shepherd Lutheran Church
1973
LCMS
Active
Milford
Grace Missionary
Active
Oak Grove
Regular Presdestinarian Baptist Order
1879
Located in A Precinct, in church minutes the official title was Regular Presdestinarian Baptist Church of Jesus Christ called Oak Grove. Minutes are located at the Seward County Historical Society.
1881, dissolved, moved and became known as the Regular Predestinarian Baptist Church of Jesus Christ Called New Hope in Butler County.
Ruby
Immanuel Evangelical
Lutheran1889
Located in J Precinct, the church closed in 1949.
Disbanded
Seward
Calvary Baptist
1963
Active
Seward
St. Vincent DePaul Catholic
1878
Active
Seward
Church of Christ
1960
Active
Seward
St. Andrew's Episcopal
1952
Active
Seward
Hillcrest Evangelical Free
1973
Active
Seward
Faith Lutheran Church
1964
ELCA. St. Paul's Lutheran of rural Milford and Our
Savior's Lutheran of Staplehurst, voted to
combine congregations forming Faith Lutheran
in Seward in 1964.Active
Seward
Grace Evangelical Lutheran
1969
WELS
Active
Seward
Living Word Lutheran
2010
LCMC
Active
Seward
Might Fortress Evangelical Lutheran
2004
AALC
Active
Seward
The Rock Lutheran
2009
LCMS
Active
Seward
St. John Lutheran
1877
LCMS
Active
Seward
United Methodist
1867
Merged with EUB in 1967
Active
Seward
Congregational
1887
Disbanded
Seward
Faith in Christ
Bible Church
Active
Seward
Lighthouse United Penticostal
Active
Seward
Friedens United Church
of Christ1878
In about 1938, the Evangelical Synod and
Reformed Church was formed. In 1957, the
Evangelical and Reformed Churches merged
with the Congregational Church to become the
United Church of Christ. Microfilmed records 1878-1973
are located at the Nebraska State Historical
Society in Lincoln.Active
Seward
Presbyterian
1868
Due to dwindling membership, the church closed
in about 2012.Disbanded
Seward
Seventh Day Adventist
1875
The congregation was organized near Ruby, but moved
to Seward.Disbanded
Seward
Evangelical United Brethern
1872
Organized about four miles northwest of Seward. In 1880,
the church was built in Seward. In 1968, the denomination
merged with the Methodist Church.Merged with UMC
Staplehurst
Immanuel Lutheran
1888
In 1966, Immanuel Lutheran and Zion Lutheran of Marysville
merged using the church in Staplehurst. The name was changed
to Our Redeemer. Microfilmed records, 1889-1966, can
be found at the Nebraska State Historical Society
in Lincoln. Active as Our Redeemer
Staplehurst
Our Savior's Lutheran
1877
The original Danish congregation, "Danish Lutheran" was affiliated with the
United Evangelical Lutheran Church. In 1964, the congregation
merged with St. Paul's Lutheran of rural Milford to form
a new church in Seward.
Merged to Faith Lutheran
Staplehurst
First Presbyterian
1882
Merged with Tamora Presbyterian Church in 1888.
Disbanded
Tamora
Presbyterian Church
1880
In 1917, the building was struck by lightning and was
not rebuilt.Disbanded
Tamora
Methodist Episcopal
1882
Closed in 1967.
Disbanded
Utica
United Methodist
1872
Active
Utica
St. Patrick's Catholic
1882
Active
Utica
St. Paul Evangelical Lutheran
1899
Missouri Synod
Active
Rural
Trinity Lutheran
1872
Located in H Precinct on Elk Slough near
the Seward-Lancaster county line. Last
services 1957.Disbanded
Rural
Prairie Grove
Methodist Protestant1872
Located in L Precinct, the congregation united with
Goehner in about 1930.Disbanded
Rural
Immanuel Lutheran
1870
Also known as Middle Creek, the church is located
on Highway 34 east of Seward several miles.Active
Rural
St. Paul's Lutheran
1890
More completely known as The Evangelical Lutheran
St. Paul' Congregation of the Unaltered Augsberg
Confession, on the Table Prairie, the congregation first
met in PS 71 in I Precinct. The congregation voted
to merge and build Faith Lutheran in Seward in 1964.Merged to Faith Lutheran
Rural
West Blue United Church of Christ
1874
The church was located in the southwest corner of
Section 36 in O Precinct. It was active in the 1970s.Disbanded
Rural
Salem United Methodist
1882
The church is located in K Precinct a couple of
miles west of Highway 15. The congregation started
meeting in the 1870s, about a mile north of
the current location. Church closed after 2010 and
has reopened as a community church. Records are at the
Methodist Archives on Wesleyan University campus
in Lincoln.Disbanded
Rural
West Fairview Mennonite
1903
The church is located one-half mile south and two
and a half miles east of Beaver Crossing in N Precinct.Active
Rural
Immanuel Evangelical Lutheran
1873
The church was located in Section 5 of D Precinct
in the northwest part of Seward County. Also known
as Meyer's Church. The church closed in 1976. Microfilmed
records, 1873-1976 are located at the Nebraska State Historical
Society in Lincoln.Disbanded
Resources
History of Seward County, Nebraska & reminiscences of territorial history, by William Wallace Cox, published 1905.
Seward County Nebraska History Supplement 1983, by The People of Seward County, copyright 1983, published by the Seward County Genealogical Society.
General History of Seward County, Nebraska, by John Waterman, published 1914-15.
Nebraska State Historical Society online record of resources.
Return to Seward County GenWeb Home Page
This page was created 1 September 2017 and updated 26 December 2022 by Joan Shurtliff.